Verlenging naturalisatietermijnen

Reactie

Vraag1

1. Longer Residency Does Not Equate to Better Integration
Extending the period from five to ten years does not inherently improve integration. In fact:
Most residents who have lived in the Netherlands for five years have already built strong ties to Dutch society: they speak the language, understand the culture, and participate in community life.
The requirements for integration, such as the inburgering exams and civic knowledge tests, already demonstrate commitment and capacity to integrate.
Research from other EU countries shows that earlier access to citizenship promotes stronger civic participation and social inclusion, whereas delay can hinder motivation.
A longer waiting period risks alienating residents who are already well integrated and eager to become full members of Dutch society.
2. Economic Contributors Deserve Recognition Without Unnecessary Delays
Many residents make substantial financial contributions to the country within their first five years:
They pay taxes, contribute to social security, and stimulate the labor market.
They fill essential roles in healthcare, technology, education, logistics, and other sectors.
Extending naturalization to ten years may discourage skilled workers from settling permanently, reducing the country's ability to attract and retain global talent.
Citizenship is not simply a legal status, but recognition of one’s contribution. If residents fulfill their obligations and meet all current legal and social requirements, there is no justified reason to withhold citizenship for an additional five years.
3. Prolonged Legal Insecurity Harms Social Stability
Without citizenship, residents lack full political, social, and legal security:
They cannot vote in national elections or fully participate in democratic processes.
They face potential limitations in employment, travel, and family rights.
4. The Proposal Creates a Competitive Disadvantage in the EU
The Netherlands has historically been seen as an open, progressive, and internationally attractive country. However:
Most EU countries maintain the five-year rule (e.g., Belgium, Sweden, France, Spain, Portugal).
Doubling the timeframe could discourage qualified migrants, international graduates, and businesses from choosing the Netherlands.
5. Families and Children Suffer Disproportionately